Race,
Gender, and Sexual Orientation Representation Throughout
America's Next Top Model
Over
the past twenty cycles America's Next Top Model
has worked and altered their cast and crew in order to appeal to a
wider audience all around. They have slowly been expanding the range
of individuals who appear throughout each season in order to present
a variety of people, all with different backgrounds and stories. This
helps the contestants relate more closely with the variety of people
that make up their viewers or audience. From the beginning of the
seasons, there have been a range of people who have appeared on this
show in a positive light, and have transformed and grew in a positive
way. America's Next Top Model
has created a wider fan base from their open-mindedness, and positive
outlook for all contestants on their show, regardless of race,
gender, or sexual orientation.
From
cycle one, Tyra banks has casted young women of all different races,
there have been white women, African-Americans, Asians, Hispanics,
and so on. From the races represented through the seasons Tyra has
made it evident that each women represented the race which she
identified with. Tyra even often appeared to sympathize and relate
to those women who shared her racial background of being
African-American. However, regardless of race, Tyra has always made
it clear that your race is not a deficit throughout this competition
or industry, but instead that your race creates your overall brand.
Hasinoff stated,
“I
argue that the abundance of discourses about feminine racialization
on America's
Next Top Model
signals a new neoliberal rhetoric of race in popular culture in which
instead of silently and superficially representing racial difference,
the show's explicit discussions about race and racialized identity
transformations are promoted as a valuable commodity” (Fashioning
Race for the Free Market on America's Next Top Model).
Overall, I agree with this statement because it is clear that for
America's Next Top Model judges this range of racial backgrounds was
often promoted as being “exotic” and valuable.
Although
Tyra often would relate physical traits, due to race or not, back to
their overall success in their photographs, there was never any
talking down or advantages throughout the competition due to racial
backgrounds. They often portrayed all contestants as equal and all
just as capable of being successful in the industry. With that being
said, they did not hold back from showing these majority or minority
women's true colors. One blog stated that, “Even
though African Americans are perceived as being “exotic” on the
show, this positive imagery is juxtaposed by negative images such as
when black contestants are shown fighting and getting into cat fights
with one another” (Racial Representations in America’s Next Top
Model). This was true throughout each season, as they did not feel as
though they needed to make these women's true personalities to the
viewers.
Aside
from racial backgrounds, for the first nineteen seasons only women
were allowed to compete in the cycles of America's Next Top
Model. While there was never any
indication as to why these rules were in play, they often casted
women who identified as being bi-sexual, homosexual, and
transgendered. Sexual orientation was never discriminated against or
looked down upon throughout the series of cycles. Beginning with the
cast members, there were commonly individuals who identified with
being homosexual present throughout the first nineteen seasons such
as Jay Manuel (photo shoot director) and J. Alexander (runway coach).
It is commonly recognized that the modeling industry is a common
setting for individuals who identify closely with being
transgendered, bi-sexual, or homosexual. This relates with Loverudes
article where she states, “Tyra
repeatedly emphasizes the importance of gay men in the industry and
encourages the contestants on ANTM to value their contributions. She
wants the women to appreciate every person who works in fashion,
regardless of sexuality” ("America's
Next Top Model Is...": Enforcing or Resisting Hegemonic
Heterosexuality).
It is an
industry where these individuals are welcome and able to express
themselves freely and be proud about who they are. Alongside the cast
members they had a large number of girls as contestants who
identified strongly and openly with being bi-sexual or homo-sexual.
In
the newest season, cycle twenty there was a change withing
the casting rules and girls and guys were both allowed to compete. In
this season the ability for men to compete made this season more
appealing to men. Within this season there was strangely only one
person who identified as being homosexual, and it was Corey, an
extremely androgynous male who expressed himself openly, and was
proud of his feminine brand. However, throughout the season it was
constantly a critique that Corey needed to be able to appear more
masculine for the photo shoots that required it. Although Corey was
constantly critiqued for his lack of masculinity within his photos,
mostly by the only male model on the panel of judges, he still pushed
through and made it to the top three. He was eliminated right before
the final runway show. After he was eliminated he stated in his
interview that he was glad that he got this opportunity, but was
excited to be able to just be his “fierce” self from now on in
his hopeful modeling career. Aside from males, there have been two
women who identified as being transgendered, Isis King, and the most
recent season with Virgg. These women were open with their
identification as female, and often expressed the difficulty that
came with this process. Virgg ended up leaving cycle twenty early on
by choice due to not feeling up to par from the medication which she
was required to take. These stories and backgrounds related closely
with many audience members, making the show more marketable to a
wider variety of people.
Overall,
America's Next Top Model has
altered their cast and crew accordingly to appeal to wider audience
base. They now have a social media score which factors into the
models overall score each week. This allows fans to rate each persons
photographs and critique them according to the public eye. During
this time in panel it expresses and presents the wide range of people
that this television show attracts. They show video responses from
public viewers which allows the contestants to see their fan base
more closely. This allows not only the contestants to see their fans,
but also the viewers to become aware of the different range of people
that this show is drawing appeal to. Regardless of America's
Next Top Model's contestants
or fan base, this wide range of gender representation, sexual
orientation, and race brings about the question as to if the show is
trying to market their show in order to gain viewers, or if this show
is trying to raise awareness about the different range of people who
are capable of making it big in the modeling world.
Sources:
Hasinoff, Amy Adele. "Fashioning Race for the Free Market on America's Next Top Model." Critical Studies in Media Communication 25.3 (2008): 324-43. Print.
Nicole.
"Racial Representations in America’s Next Top Model." We
Love Media Criticism.
N.p., 19 Oct. 2009. Web. 17 Nov. 2013.
<http://welovemediacrit.blogspot.com/2009/10/racial- representations-in-americas-next.html>.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.