So, I literally do not watch TV, or
TV shows that I could talk about with my friends. I do occasionally tune in to “Friday-
Bride-day” on TLC, “Toddlers and Tiaras,” or the Kardashians...but I do not
keep up with them. I do though think that people compare their lives to many of
the television shows they watch when overhearing conversations. I always hear
my friends say, “OMG, I AM SO BLAIR.” I assume that they want to live vicariously
through this person on TV because they have a fun and dramatic live. What
really interest me are the television shows whose actual goal is to teach
people how to be the character. Dora the Explorer is supposed to teach kids a
different language, which is Spanish, and learn a different culture. It is
obvious that the culture that is trying to be portrayed is a Latino culture,
but it is unclear to what culture. With an unspecified Latino culture can be
beneficial and detrimental to the way the Hispanic community might be viewed
as.
Dora the Explorer is a character
that represents a Latino child that travels and adventures through the world.
This television show was originally designed to teach American children
Spanish, and teach them about teamwork, ethics, and culture. Dora Marquez is
seen as a big Hispanic icon. Everyone knows the theme song with a couple of
Spanish words that make you feel bilingual. When watching the show, you assume
that the show is about a Hispanic (Mexican) little girl with her friend who
tries to find things that have been stolen from her. But when does the show
mention she is Mexican? Is it because of her accent? Or is it because of the
cultural references that they make. In fact, the show never mentions anything
about race. In many pages like Wikipedia, Dora is just mentioned as a Hispanic/Latina
girl. I have googled what ethnicity and nationality Dora is, and the only
answer I can find is Latina or Hispanic. But the truth is that being Hispanic
does not narrow down what country she is from, what her culture is like, or
what the different customs and traditions are.
The most obvious thing that tells us
that shows she is Latina, is the skin color. She has a dark/medium skin tone,
dark brown hair, and brown eyes. Her name is Latina and she speaks Spanish
fluently. She calls her parents “mama” and “papa.” She also calls her
grandmother “abuelita.” So what kind of Latina is she? The answer is; all of
them. Notice how her clothes are very generic like any other Nickelodeon cartoon.
She is well educated and independent which indicate she is in the middle class.
In an article by Guidotti- Hernandez, she
believes that Dora does not represent any particular culture from Latin
America, but represents a pan-Latino culture. This portrays the image of the
Latino as one very generic group. We can see this by the way that the culture
is never specified and is given various mixtures of different cultures. There
is different music, traditions, clothing, accents, and ways of acting among society.
All of these different things are a mixture of many Latino countries. When
analyzing this, I can find both a positive and negative side to having Dora
Portray a pan-Latino culture.
Since the Latino population is a
minority in the United States, it is good that the culture is being introduced
in a positive way. It is also important that the children get exposed to
something different than the standard American culture. This cartoon shows the
children that there is a different language and that there is a positive tide
with the Spanish language. The Spanish language is one of the major languages
that are spoken by the majority of the Latin American countries, which makes a
positive impact. Also, by representing the Latino community as a whole, it allows
for less discrimination to some of the Latino groups within the Latino
community. But is the Latino community actually being represented, as they want
to be represented?
Guidotti-Hernandez says no. He
believes that the Latino culture does not have the power to change and create
this stereotype being created by Dora. He believes that Nickelodeon is the one
that is setting the standards for all the cultures and making it into one. This
is conflicting because the cultures aren’t accepted as they specifically are
because there is a norm that people expect all Hispanics to follow. I believe
otherwise with he statement because of the positive teaching that is done
through this kids’ television show.
I personally believe that by showing
different minorities in popular television shows, with a positive stigma,
people will actually take a positive view of the culture. Dora is a neutral
character that represents any Latino child in someone’s classroom. I think in
this instance, Dora is not being detrimental to the stereotypes put on Latinos
because it is a show that is mostly viewed by other children. If this were an adult
show, I do believe that many people would have Dora as a standard for every
Latino, and maybe feel negativity towards any Latino who didn’t meet Dora’s
expectations. Since it is a fun cartoon that tries to involve and teach
children, I’d say it’s harmless.
"Dora
the Explorer." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Sept. 2013. Web.
26 Sept. 2013.
Guidotti-Hernández,
Nicole M. "Dora The Explorer, Constructing “LATINIDADES” and The Politics
of Global Citizenship." Latino Studies 5.2 (2007): 209-32. Print.
"What
Is Dora the Explorer's Ethnicity?" Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo!, n.d.
Web. 26 Sept. 2013.
Well, the way I see it Dora is actually a Hispanic from the Caribbean. They use mostly Caribbean rythms in the show, (Salsa and Merengue, are DEFINATELLY NOT MEXICAN MUSIC)... the accents and items used to portray her character are almost always from the area. Its logical since the only Hispanics who are natural born Americans are Puerto Ricans (..yes there are some dark skinned Puerto Ricans). Culturally speaking, Mexicans (and Argentinians) are quite different from the other Hispanic groups and can't be accommodated easily in a general Hispanic audience as Dora's show finds easy to do. although I think Mexican Americans kids who live in multicultural areas can probably fit into Doras format somewhat.. All in all Its a very good idea to integrate little Hispanics into the national culture as well as teaching our kids a little Spanish, this help to unite our nation a little more.
ReplyDelete